Why More New Yorkers Are Choosing Cars Over Subway: The Transportation Shift

The city that never sleeps is waking up to a new reality: more New Yorkers are saying goodbye to crowded platforms and hello to car keys.

Picture this: It's 8:30 AM on a Tuesday, and you're standing shoulder-to-shoulder with dozens of strangers on a delayed F train that's been "held momentarily by train traffic ahead" for the past 15 minutes. Your important meeting starts in 20 minutes, and you're still three stops away. Sound familiar?

If you're nodding your head, you're not alone. Across New York City, a quiet revolution is taking place—one that's fundamentally changing how New Yorkers get around. Car ownership in NYC has surged dramatically, with over 223,500 more vehicles registered from 2012 to 2021—a remarkable 12.1% increase that brought the city's total from 1.85 million to 2.08 million vehicles. This trend has continued through 2025, with industry data showing sustained growth in vehicle registrations across New York State. This trend has continued through 2025, even as subway ridership has paradoxically also grown, with the MTA hitting over 850 million customers in just the first half of 2025. This isn't just a number; it's a statement about how residents are reimagining their relationship with transportation in the nation's most transit-dependent city.

The Great NYC Transportation Awakening

For decades, New York prided itself on being different. While the rest of America drove everywhere, New Yorkers hopped on subways, walked, and occasionally hailed a cab. Car ownership was seen as unnecessary, even burdensome. Parking was a nightmare, traffic was worse, and the subway could get you anywhere you needed to go.

But something shifted in the past decade. The romance with public transit began to fade as reality set in.

The Bronx led this automotive awakening with a staggering 22% increase in vehicle registrations. Manhattan and Brooklyn weren't far behind, each seeing 13% growth. Even in neighborhoods where car ownership was once unthinkable, residents started making space in their budgets—and their lives—for vehicles.

The Paradox of 2025: More Cars AND More Subway Riders

Here's where the story gets interesting: 2025 has brought us a transportation paradox that defies conventional wisdom. While car ownership has continued its upward trajectory, subway ridership is also surging. Combined buses and subways carried over 850 million customers in just the first half of 2025, and weekday subway ridership averaged 4 million rides per day in March for the first time since 2019.

2024 subway annual ridership rose to 1.195 billion, reflecting a 3.7% year-over-year increase and reaching 70% of pre-pandemic levels. Weekend ridership recovery has been particularly strong, climbing 4.3% annually to an average of 4.42 million, equaling 80% of pre-pandemic levels.

So what's happening? New Yorkers aren't choosing between cars and subways—they're choosing both, but for different purposes. The subway remains the workhorse for Manhattan commutes, while cars provide the flexibility for everything else: weekend trips, outer borough destinations, family obligations, and those moments when you simply can't afford to be at the mercy of service disruptions.

When "Good Service" Isn't Good Enough

The numbers tell a story that every New York commuter knows by heart. Despite recent improvements in some metrics, the fundamental experience of riding the subway has become increasingly unreliable and, for many, unacceptable.

Consider the daily reality: Despite the MTA reporting record performance levels in 2025—with weekday subway on-time performance at 83.7% in the first six months—many New Yorkers still experience the gap between statistics and lived experience. An 83.7% on-time rate means that roughly one in six trips involves delays, and those delays tend to cluster during the times you most need reliable service.

Recent data shows major crimes in the subway system declined by 5.4% in 2024, yet perception of safety issues persists, affecting ridership decisions for many families, particularly during off-peak hours.

"I used to pride myself on being car-free," says Maria Rodriguez, a marketing executive from Queens who bought her first car in 2019. "But when you're late to work three times a week because of subway delays, and you're paying $130 a month for unreliable service, the math starts to change."

The math Maria refers to is becoming clearer to more New Yorkers every day. A monthly MetroCard costs $132, but OMNY weekly caps and fare increases have made transit costs even more visible. Add in the occasional Uber when the subway fails you, the premium you pay for apartments near multiple subway lines, and the time cost of unpredictable commutes, and car ownership starts looking like a bargain.

The Freedom Factor

Beyond the practical considerations lies something more fundamental: freedom. Car ownership in New York isn't just about getting from Point A to Point B—it's about reclaiming control over your time and choices.

With a car, you can:

• Visit family in New Jersey without planning your entire day around NJ Transit schedules
• Take spontaneous weekend trips to the Hudson Valley or Long Island beaches
• Shop at stores with better prices and selection outside Manhattan
• Avoid the stress of crowded platforms during rush hour
• Maintain social distancing when health concerns arise
• Transport larger items without the logistics nightmare of subway stairs

"Having a car changed my entire relationship with the city," explains James Chen, a software developer from Brooklyn. "I'm no longer limited to a subway map when making plans. I can explore neighborhoods I never would have visited, and I can leave the city whenever I want without checking train schedules."

The Numbers Don't Lie

The surge in car ownership wasn't confined to one or two boroughs. From 2012 to 2021, vehicle registrations grew by 52,000 in the Bronx, 59,000 in Queens, and 66,000 in Brooklyn. Even Manhattan, the most transit-dense borough, added 23,000 vehicles.

This growth happened during a period when the city's population grew by only 1.4%, meaning car ownership per capita increased dramatically. New Yorkers weren't just buying more cars because there were more people—existing residents were making the switch.

As of 2025, nearly 71% of New York households have access to at least one vehicle, according to the latest data, while NYC still maintains the lowest car ownership rate in the nation at around 45.6% for the city proper.

The pandemic initially accelerated this trend, but the data shows it was already well underway. From 2012 to 2019, before COVID-19 entered the picture, the city had already gained 171,100 new households, but less than a tenth of that increase was in zero-car households. Recent trends through 2024 and into 2025 show this pattern continuing, even as subway ridership simultaneously recovers.

Breaking Down the Barriers

What made this shift possible? Several factors converged to make car ownership more attractive and accessible:

Financial accessibility improved. Low interest rates, competitive auto loan offers, and a robust used car market made monthly car payments comparable to—or sometimes less than—the combined cost of public transit and ride-sharing services.

Technology smoothed the rough edges. Apps for finding parking, navigation systems that route around traffic, and mobile payments for parking meters eliminated many traditional pain points of city driving.

Infrastructure adapted. While still challenging, parking became more manageable with the growth of residential parking permits, new parking facilities, and better enforcement of existing spaces.

Work patterns changed. Even before the pandemic normalized remote work, more New Yorkers were working non-traditional hours or in locations not well-served by public transit.

The Real Cost of Car-Free Living

Many New Yorkers are discovering that car-free living isn't as economical as it once appeared. Consider the true monthly cost in 2025:

• OMNY weekly cap translates to roughly $140+ monthly for regular commuters
• Average monthly Uber/Lyft for situations when subway isn't practical: $100-200
• Premium rent for transit-accessible neighborhoods: $300-500 extra per month
• Time cost of delays and unreliable service: Priceless

When you add it up, car ownership—especially with favorable financing—often costs the same or less while providing significantly more value and convenience.

Making the Switch: Smart Financing for Smart Decisions

For New Yorkers ready to join the transportation revolution, smart financing makes all the difference. Today's auto loan market offers opportunities that didn't exist a decade ago, with low rates, making monthly payments manageable even in New York's expensive market.

The key is working with lenders who understand the unique needs of New York car buyers—from first-time buyers who've never needed credit for a vehicle to experienced drivers looking to upgrade or refinance existing loans.

Whether you're buying your first car, financing a newer model, or refinancing to get better terms, the right loan can make the difference between car ownership being a burden and being the freedom you've been looking for.

The Road Ahead

The shift toward car ownership in New York represents more than a transportation trend—it's a fundamental change in how residents define urban living. As more New Yorkers discover the benefits of having their own wheels, the city itself is adapting, with new parking policies, infrastructure improvements, and services designed for the growing population of car owners.

This doesn't mean the subway is obsolete. Public transit will always play a crucial role in New York's transportation ecosystem. But for a growing number of residents, it's no longer the only option—or even the best one.

The question isn't whether you should consider car ownership in New York. The question is: what's keeping you from exploring your options?

Ready to explore auto financing options that work for New York lifestyles? Contact us to learn about competitive rates and flexible terms designed with New York car buyers in mind. Because your time is valuable, and your transportation should work for you—not against you.

Join Thousands of New Yorkers Who Made the Switch to Car Ownership

Local lender, competitive rates, personalized service. Your freedom starts here. [Check Your Auto Loan Options]